BAWJ

News & events

News

News29 October 2026

Judge Teodora Karabasheva about the I-JUMP program

The representative of the Bulgarian Association of Women Judges in the International Judicial Mentoring Programme ( I-JUMP ), organized by the International Training Committee of the Judicial College of England and Wales Author: Teodora Karabasheva, Judge at Sofia Regional Court It is with genuine joy, gratitude and a deep sense of professional responsibility that I take part in the International Judicial Mentoring Programme (I-JUMP), organised by the International Training Committee of the Judicial College of England and Wales, as a representative of the Association of Women Judges in Bulgaria. The programme runs for six months, during which I will be paired with Judge Michelle Smith from Birmingham, England. I see this as a valuable opportunity to exchange professional experience, discuss the challenges of facing the judiciary and gain a deeper understanding of the judge as the person under the robe . I believe that being a good judge means not only having a thorough knowledge of the law and taking responsibility for one’s decisions, but also remaining committed to lifelong learning and continuous professional development. This is one of the principal reasons why I embraced the opportunity to participate in the programme with such enthusiasm. Over the upcoming six months, I hope to broaden my professional horizons, learn more about good practices within the common law tradition, and deepen my understanding of issues such as judicial independence and professional ethics. My participation in the programme also opens the door to a more in-depth exploration of how judges build and sustain public confidence in the judiciary, how they foster professional resilience and well-being, and how they respond to the complex challenges which arise in a rapidly evolving social and technological community. What I particularly value about international initiatives of this kind is the opportunity to look beyond the boundaries of our own legal systems, exchange experiences, and identify approaches and solutions that may offer valuable insights and have relevance across different jurisdictions. I firmly believe that mentoring is a two-way process: it is not simply an opportunity to acquire knowledge, but also to share one’s own experience, ask questions, challenge assumptions and reflect critically on established practices. I also see my participation as an opportunity to contribute to this dialogue by sharing my professional experience and perspective on the judicial work in Bulgaria. Every legal system has its own distinctive features, yet the pursuit of independent, competent and fair justice is a shared value. It is a privilege to be part of an international initiative of this kind. I approach it with an open mind, curiosity and a genuine willingness to learn, deeply convinced that the advancement of justice also depends on the willingness of those who serve it to continue learning, reflecting and growing throughout their professional lives. I share the idea that a strong judiciary is built not only on laws and institutions, but also on professionals who are willing to learn from one another, share knowledge and uphold common values — growing together, supporting one another and working side by side in the name of improvement of justice.

Article22 October 2026

Electronic evidence in criminal proceedings

Electronic evidence in criminal proceedings: the European legal framework and the Bulgarian legislative reform Author : Judge Marieta Nedelcheva, District Court – Sofia, member of the Board of Directors of the Bulgarian Judicial Association and national contact person in the National Judicial Network of Bulgaria, contact point in the European Judicial Network S ummary: The article examines the European legal framework for cross-border collection of electronic evidence, established by Regulation (EU) 2023/1543 and Directive (EU) 2023/1544, in comparison with the proposals set out in the explanatory memorandum to the draft Act amending and supplementing the Code of Criminal Procedure. The analysis covers the categories of data, the competence of the issuing authorities, the interaction with service providers and the protection of the persons concerned. It is argued that the effectiveness of the reform depends on combining rapid access to data with consistent procedural guarantees, technical reliability and a justified choice of the applicable legal instrument. Keywords: electronic evidence, criminal proceedings, European Production Order, European Preservation Order, mutual recognition, judicial review. I. Introduction Digitalization is significantly changing both the ways in which crimes are committed and the possibilities for proving them. Electronic correspondence, data on the use of communication services, device recordings and information in the cloud environment can be crucial for establishing authorship, the mechanism of the act and the relationships between the participants. Electronic evidence encompasses a variety of sources, the collection of which requires a distinction between the applicable procedural methods. The main challenge in collecting electronic evidence stems from the mismatch between the territorial organisation of criminal justice and the cross-border nature of digital services. The country of investigation, the place of establishment of the provider and the location of the data may be different, and there is a real risk that the information will be deleted or modified before traditional international legal assistance procedures are completed. The European e-evidence package (Regulation (EU) 2023/1543 and Directive (EU) 2023/1544) offers a response to the challenges encountered through direct interaction between competent authorities and designated addressees of service providers. The adoption of common rules for the collection of e-evidence is an important step, but their successful implementation requires constant monitoring, control and cooperation. Therefore, speed of access cannot be the only criterion for effectiveness. The information obtained needs to be collected lawfully and be subject to verification in a fair criminal trial. II. Negotiations and adoption of the e-evidence package The legislative package proposed by the European Commission in 2018 was adopted after lengthy negotiations. Among the most contentious issues in the discussion of the regulations is the involvement of the state in which the order is addressed: when its authorities must be notified and on what grounds they can refuse execution. The final model combines direct transmission to the provider with control by the executing state in certain cases. The two acts fulfil different but complementary functions. Regulation (EU) 2023/1543 regulates European Production and Preservation Orders, the conditions for their issuance and the procedures for their enforcement. Directive (EU) 2023/1544 lays down rules for determining the forms of establishment and representatives to receive and enforce the relevant acts. The Regulation applies from 18 August 2026, and the deadline for transposition of the Directive is 18 February 2026. In the Bulgarian context, the motivations for the draft Law on Amendments and Supplements to the Criminal Procedure Code, published on 03.09.2026 on the Public Consultation Portal of the Council of Ministers, envisage simultaneously ensuring the implementation of the Regulation, transposing the Directive and preparing for ratification of the Second Additional Protocol to the Convention on Cybercrime of the Council of Europe (the so-called Budapest Convention). III. Key elements of the European package and its national adaptation 1. The Electronic Evidence Regulation a) Subject matter, scope and categories of data The Regulation introduces a European Production Order and a European Preservation Order for electronic evidence. These instruments are defined as decisions issued or confirmed by a judicial authority of a Member State and addressed to a designated institution or legal representative of a service provider offering services in the Union and established in another Member State, for the purpose of producing electronic evidence or preserving electronic evidence with a view to a subsequent request for production. With the European Preservation Order, judicial authorities can prevent foreign service providers from erasing or modifying data, while the European Production Order enables authorities to request preserved information directly from service providers immediately or at a later stage. To this end, the Regulation regulates the conditions for issuing these instruments, their execution by service providers, the notification and grounds for refusal to the executing Member State, the procedure for application and imposition of sanctions, the rights of the persons whose data are sought, the review procedure in the event of conflicting obligations with the laws of a third country, the provisions on standardised certificates and the decentralised information system and finally the rules governing costs. However, the Regulation does not provide for a complete and exhaustive set of rules governing the application of the European Production Order and the European Preservation Order, but instead repeatedly refers to the rules provided for in national law. In terms of personal and territorial scope, the Regulation focuses on service providers offering services in the Union. The determination of whether a service provider offers services in the Union is based on an assessment of two cumulative requirements. The first requirement concerns the availability of services in a Member State, while the second requires that there is a substantial connection, based on specific factual criteria, with that Member State or those Member States of the Union. The mechanism provided for in the Regulation covers information already held by or on behalf of a service provider. It is not a tool for continuous real-time surveillance or interception of future communications. In the event that the collection of such information in real time, which involves the use of specific intelligence means in an international context, is sought, a European Investigation Order should be issued, in accordance with the requirements of Directive 2014/41 on the European Investigation Order. Article 3, point 8 of the Regulation distinguishes electronic evidence as subscriber data, traffic data or content data stored by a service provider or on behalf of a service provider in electronic form at the time of receipt of a European Production Order certificate or an electronic preservation order certificate. The competent authority and the conditions for issuing the order depend on the category of electronic evidence the issuing authority needs to preserve or produce. b) Competence and conditions for issuance For the provision of subscriber data and data requested solely for the purpose of identifying the user, it is permissible to issue or confirm the order by a competent prosecutor. According to the definition given in Art. 3, point 10 of the Regulation, data requested solely for the purpose of identifying the user are "IP addresses and, where necessary, the relevant ports at the source and the time stamp, namely the date and time or the technical equivalent of these identifiers and the information related to them, when this is required by law enforcement or judicial authorities solely for the purpose of identifying the user in a specific criminal investigation". Thus, the reasons for the draft Act on Amendments and Supplements to the Criminal Procedure Code, which is published on the Public Consultation Portal, propose a new para.7 of Art. 159a of the Criminal Procedure Code. It is envisaged that for certain data required solely for the purpose of establishing the identity of the user and not related to making calls or transmitting messages, the general procedure under Art. 159 of the Code of Criminal Procedure is envisaged. The identification purpose must be explicitly stated in the request. For other traffic data and content data, the issuance or validation of an Order for the provision of electronic evidence by a judge, a court, or an investigating judge is required, in accordance with Article 4, paragraph 2 of the Regulation. This distinction reflects the different intensity of the interference with the fundamental rights of the persons concerned. In view of the above, the draft Act on the Criminal Procedure Code provides for the creation of Article 159c, with paragraph 2 stating that for traffic data the request is sent by the court in the court proceedings or by the supervising prosecutor in the pre-trial proceedings on the basis of a reasoned order of a judge of the relevant court of first instance, issued in accordance with Article 159a, paragraphs 2-5 of the Criminal Procedure Code. Despite the wording of the said provision, in this case, when issuing European orders for the provision of traffic data during pre-trial proceedings, the judgment in case C – 724/19 of the Court of Justice of the EU should be taken into account and the decision given in Art. 5, para. 1, letter “c” of the European Investigation Order Act (amended by SG, issue 36 of 2024) should be accepted as an EIO of traffic data should be issued by the relevant court of first instance on the basis of a reasoned request by the supervising prosecutor. This is so, since the only competent authority to order the specific action on the investigation in a national case, according to Art. 159a, para. 1 of the Criminal Procedure Code is the relevant court of first instance. This conclusion also follows from the norm of Art. 4, paragraph 2, letter “a” of the Regulation (personal opinion expressed by the author of the article) . In all cases, the order must be necessary, proportionate and admissible under the same conditions in a similar national case, taking into account the rights of the suspect or accused. The provision of traffic data is generally subject to the requirement that the offence is punishable by a maximum term of imprisonment of at least three years, in the special cases provided for in the Regulation (Article 5(4) of the Regulation). This threshold does not override the other prerequisites for access. In this regard, the draft Amendment to the Criminal Procedure Code proposes the deletion of the word “intentional” in paragraph 2 of Article 159a of the Criminal Procedure Code (regarding the types of offences for the investigation of which traffic data may be collected). It is also stated that the requirement of “serious intent” goes beyond the provisions of Article 34, paragraph 2 of the Constitution, according to which an exception to the principle of inviolability of the secret of correspondence and other communications is allowed only with the permission of the judiciary, when this is necessary for the detection or prevention of serious crimes, without explicitly indicating the form of guilt. In this way, the competent authorities are deprived of the opportunity to gain access to traffic data, including location data, with a view to detecting serious crimes committed through negligence. The explanatory memorandum to the draft of the Criminal Procedure Code provides an example that in the Criminal Code there are a number of criminal offenses in which the result of the act committed through negligence is sufficiently significant, such as a traffic accident with a fatality or many injured persons. This change requires careful delineation of the boundary between identification and investigation of communication activity. A formally stated goal should not be sufficient if the volume and combination of information allow for the reconstruction of contacts or behavior. c) Implementation, deadlines and control The general time limit for providing data on the basis of a received European Production Order is at the latest ten days, and in case of urgency – at the latest eight hours, taking into account the rules for notifying the executing authority. In the case of retention, the initial time limit is 60 days with the possibility of an extension of another 30 days. The timely confirmation of a subsequent request for production determines the retention for the necessary time until its execution. For specific traffic data and content orders, pursuant to Article 8 of the Regulation, the issuing authority shall simultaneously notify the executing authority by transmitting the European Production Order certificate to that authority at the same time as transmitting the certificate to its addressee (the designated form of establishment or to the representative of the relevant service provider). The exception to not notifying the executing authority is related to the existence of grounds to assume both that the offence has a connection with the issuing State as provided for in the Regulation and that the person concerned resides in it. This assessment is essential, as it determines the executing State's ability to invoke the grounds for refusal. Therefore, sending directly to the provider does not remove control, but changes its distribution. This significantly increases the responsibility of the issuing authority for the correct qualification of the data and the motivation of the order. d) Notification and legal remedies The Regulation provides for notification of the individual about the provision of his/her data and effective judicial protection against the European Production Order, including challenging its necessity and proportionality. Restriction or postponement of notification is permissible under established conditions and requires justification. The explanatory memorandum to the draft of the Criminal Procedure Code Act links the national amendments to the case law of the Court of Justice of the EU in case C‑350/21 and of the ECtHR in the case of “Ekimdzhiev and Others v. Bulgaria”. It is proposed to create a new Art. 159e in the Criminal Procedure Code for notification of the affected person and amendments to the Law on liability of the state and municipalities for damages regarding the liability of the state in the event of unlawful access to traffic data. These remedies should operate as a coherent mechanism. Notification enables challenge, judicial review establishes the lawfulness of the interference, and compensation provides protection in the event of harm. None of the elements can fully replace the others. 2. The Directive on the designation of addressees Directive (EU) 2023/1544 requires providers to designate a form of establishment or representative with the necessary powers and resources to receive and execute relevant decisions and orders. This creates a predictable channel of communication and reduces legal uncertainty for both authorities and private parties. The functions of these addressees are not limited to the Regulation, but also cover other instruments referred to in the Directive. The explanatory memorandum to the draft Law on Amendments to the Criminal Procedure Code provides for the transposition of the Directive by introducing amendments to the Electronic Communications Act and the Electronic Commerce Act, including sanctions for non-compliance. According to the Regulation, all written communications between national authorities and designated entities or legal representatives of service providers shall be carried out through a secure and reliable decentralised information system. The annexes to the Regulation contain the forms to be used. In order to correctly complete the forms for issuing European Preservation Orders and European Production Orders under the Sirius project, manuals have been prepared, which indicate the data and information to be filled in. The draft of the Criminal Procedure Code Act proposes that the Communications Regulation Commission, within 6 months of the law coming into force, establishes and maintains a separate e-CODEX access point, which enables digital connectivity within the EU and through which the addressees specified by the Electronic Communications Act and the Electronic Commerce Act will connect to the decentralized information system in order to receive a certificate for a European Production and Preservation Order for electronic evidence. This is a national organizational decision, justified in the reasoning by security requirements and the separation of access by private providers from the internal systems of judicial institutions. IV. Consequences for stakeholders 1. Judicial and investigative authorities The new regime requires not only knowledge of the forms, but also the ability to choose the appropriate legal instrument. The choice may be influenced by costs, convenience of communication channel or familiarity with a particular procedure, rather than a comprehensive assessment of the specific case. Of additional importance for Bulgarian practice are the proposals in the draft Criminal Procedure Code Act for access to traffic data in the case of serious negligent crimes, as well as for updating the regime of electronic correspondence under Art. 165 of the Criminal Procedure Code. They aim to overcome restrictions that, according to the motives, make the investigation difficult and do not correspond to modern communication technologies. However, the expanded capabilities require an individual assessment of the scope and urgency of the intervention. It is necessary to distinguish between securing a device against loss of information and access to protected content. The mere presence of a digital medium does not justify unlimited examination of all data stored on it. 2. Service providers Providers must organize timely processing of orders, protection of confidentiality and integrity of information, and communication in case of legal or factual obstacles. Direct interaction assigns significant responsibilities to the private sector without making the provider a substitute for the judicial authority. Cases of conflict with obligations under the law of a third country are particularly complex. For these, a special review procedure is foreseen, including a judicial review when maintaining the order. This shows that independence from the physical location of the data does not eliminate all possible conflicts between jurisdictions. 3. Affected persons and protection The possibility for the suspect, the accused or his lawyer to request the issuance of a warrant is also important for the collection of evidence relevant to the defense of the accused. It must be practically usable, especially when the information is fragile and delay may lead to its loss. Lawful receipt does not prejudge the probative value. The court must assess the reliability, context and connection of the information with the rest of the evidence . The European mechanism facilitates access but does not exempt national authorities from verifying the evidence while respecting the right to a fair trial and the rights of the defence. V. Relationships with international instruments and choice of legal basis Article 32(1) of the Regulation preserves the applicability of other instruments, agreements and arrangements for gathering evidence. European Production and Preservation Orders do not automatically replace the European Investigation Order or the applicable international legal assistance mechanisms. In this case, the advantage is flexibility. In an investigation requiring different actions, the European Investigation Order may be a more appropriate instrument, covering not only information from a provider but also other sources of evidence, respectively the performance of other investigative measures . A combination of mechanisms is also permissible - for example, a European Preservation Order followed by a request for production under another applicable procedure with a European Investigation Order. In view of the introduction of the new regime for collecting electronic evidence in criminal proceedings, the following conclusions should be drawn: First of all, a precise distinction is needed between the categories of data, in particular between the identification of the user and the investigation of his communication activity, for which European orders for the production of electronic evidence will be issued in the future. The distinction should be determined by the actual content and scope of the interference, and not only by the wording of the request. Second, expanding access to electronic information must be accompanied by effective mechanisms for notification, redress, and redress. Procedural speed cannot compensate for the lack of effective protection. Last but not least, the regulatory framework, digital infrastructure and professional training must develop in a coherent manner. Otherwise, the choice of instrument may be determined by organisational difficulties rather than the legal specificities of the case. The success of the reform in the field of collecting electronic evidence is therefore not measured solely by obtaining information more quickly. Its criterion is the ability of the criminal justice system to transform the digital data collected in a timely manner into reliable and verifiable evidence= Sources used: 1. Regulation ( EU ) 2023/1543 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 12 July 2023 on European Production Orders and European Preservation Orders for electronic evidence in criminal proceedings and for the execution of custodial sentences resulting from criminal proceedings 2. Directive ( EU ) 2023/1544 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 12 July 2023 establishing harmonised rules on the determination of certain forms of establishment and the designation of representatives for the purposes of collecting electronic evidence in criminal proceedings 3. EUR-Lex website – section “Electronic evidence in criminal proceedings” https://eur-lex.europa.eu/BG/legal-content/summary/electronic-evidence-in-criminal-proceedings.html 4. The Council of the EU website, section "Better access to electronic evidence in the fight against crime" - https://www.consilium.europa.eu/bg/policies/e-evidence/#e-evidence 5. Draft Law on Amendments and Supplements to the Criminal Procedure Code and the Motives thereto, published on 03.09.2026 on the Public Consultations Portal of the Council of Ministers 6. The E-evidence Package, The Happy Ending of the Long Negotiation Saga, Gianluca Forlani , eucrim , Issue 2/2023 , pp 174-181 7. The Use of Electronic Evidence in European Area of Freedom, Security and Justice /An Introduction to the New EU Package of E-evidence/, Adam Juszczak and Elisa Sason , eucrim , Vol.18/2/ , pp 182-200 8. European Preservation and Production orders A Non-Exclusive approach to E-Evidence within the EU, Jorge A. Espina Ramos, eucrim , Issue 3/2025, pp 216-220 9. European Judicial Network website, E-Evidence section https://www.ejn-crimjust.europa.eu/ejn2021/ContentDetail/BG/6/88 10. Eurojust website , E-Evidence section https://www.eurojust.europa.eu/judicial-cooperation/instruments/electronic-evidence 11. Guidelines for completing the form for issuing a European Production Order, prepared under the Sirius project https://www.ejn-crimjust.europa.eu/ejnupload/CMT/TopicsInFocus/SIRIUS-Guidelines-for-Completing-the-European-Production-Order-Certificate-EPOC-en.pdf 12. Guidelines for completing the form for issuing a European Preservation Order, prepared under the Sirius project https://www.ejn-crimjust.europa.eu/ejnupload/CMT/TopicsInFocus/SIRIUS-Guidelines-for-Completing-the-European-preservation-Order-certificate-EPOC-PR-en.pdf

Article18 October 2026

Artificial Intelligence in the California Judicial System

Artificial Intelligence in the California Judicial System – An Inside Look kalina stancheva judge at sofia regional court president of bawj Navigating Technological Capabilities, Judicial Independence, and Human Judgment During a professional training program in San Francisco, USA—featuring speakers from the University of California and Stanford University—various aspects of the future of law, dispute resolution, and the role of new technologies in the work of legal professionals were examined. Within the context of judicial proceedings, the use of artificial intelligence takes on particular significance; it raises questions not only regarding the efficiency of the justice system but also concerning its fundamental principles—such as independence, impartiality, integrity, personal accountability, and the process by which a judge forms their inner conviction. California serves as an intriguing example of how technological advancement is gradually reshaping daily life and creating new challenges for institutions, including the judiciary. In San Francisco, these shifts are evident not only in professional discourse but also within the urban landscape. Autonomous vehicles operated by "Waymo" now navigate the streets without a human driver, and encountering robots in the city has become increasingly commonplace—no longer resembling scenes from a science fiction film. Such observations illustrate how rapidly technologies, once considered part of a distant future, are becoming an integral part of everyday life. It is inevitable that this global transformation will also leave its mark on the administration of justice. Artificial intelligence can be used to support legal research, process large volumes of information, and carry out administrative tasks. However, alongside these capabilities, questions arise regarding the reliability of generated content, the protection of personal data, accountability in decision-making, and the risk of perpetuating existing biases. As autonomous technologies become part of the public sphere, the question of how the legal system should respond to them takes on not only theoretical but also immediate practical significance. In May 2024, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of California established a special working group on artificial intelligence, tasked with developing recommendations for its use within the judicial system. The issues under consideration include ways to facilitate access to justice, the risks associated with the creation of fabricated evidence, and the use of artificial intelligence in conducting legal research. As of September 1, 2025, specific rules regarding the use of generative artificial intelligence in courts have come into effect in California. These rules emphasize verifying the accuracy of generated information, protecting confidential data, and preventing harmful or discriminatory outcomes. This approach highlights the necessity for technological advancement to be accompanied by clear regulations and accountability in the use of new tools. A similar need should be taken into account when shaping national policies in Bulgaria. One of the fundamental issues concerns the boundary between technological support and a judge’s independent judgment. Artificial intelligence can provide information, organize arguments, and assist in handling specific cases. At the same time, there is a risk that it may generate non-existent judicial decisions, inaccurate legal arguments, or claims that appear convincing yet are fundamentally flawed. Consequently, the use of any artificial intelligence tool does not absolve a judge of the duty to verify the reliability of the information received and to form their own conviction independently. In this context, the protection of judicial independence becomes particularly significant. When algorithmic tools influence the perception of facts, the assessment of evidence, or the selection of the applicable legal norm, the question arises as to the extent to which the final decision is the product of independent human judgment. Even when a system creates an impression of objectivity, its outputs are shaped by the data used, its underlying operational logic, and inherent limitations—factors that are not always apparent to the user. Equal importance should be placed on the training of magistrates. Responsible use of new technologies requires an understanding of their capabilities, their limitations, and, crucially, the challenges associated with them. Skills should be developed to identify inaccuracies, algorithmic biases, and privacy risks—all while remaining open to the potential benefits of technological innovation. Achieving this goal requires an ongoing dialogue among judges, the academic community, IT specialists, and the institutions responsible for establishing the rules for the use of artificial intelligence. The development of technology necessitates that the question of its application be considered alongside the question of the values ​​that must be preserved during the modernization of the justice system. It is important to consider not only whether artificial intelligence can accelerate a judge’s work, but also under what conditions greater efficiency can be achieved without compromising the rights of citizens—and, above all, public trust in the courts. Ultimately, a modern justice system is defined by more than just the speed of adjudication. It requires the ability to harness technological progress without losing the human dimension in the resolution of disputes. Behind every legal case lie real people and human lives. Therefore, even if artificial intelligence serves as a valuable tool, the responsibility for reaching a fair decision must remain in the hands of the human being entrusted with the administration of justice.

News18 October 2026

Confidence in the procedure, risks facing the new SJC, and recommendations from the public

Alongside the campaign for the election of a new composition of the Supreme Judicial Council (SJC), the number of people from the general public completing our survey continues to grow. We will summarize the results once the procedure concludes. For now, we are publishing the responses to the open-ended questions—offering a glimpse into the sentiments and attitudes surrounding these elections within the judicial system . What would most increase your confidence in the procedure for electing a new SJC? · Complete transparency. · Minimizing the weight of subjective assessments in the selection process; developing a highly objective system for evaluating candidates' qualifications and for the voting procedure itself. Amending the rules to prevent illegitimate members from continuing to serve beyond their official term. The current situation is a disgrace to the entire judicial system. · At this stage, candidates should demonstrate a clear stance, identify systemic issues within the judiciary, and outline specific needs and mechanisms for effectively resolving them. · Public presentation of the candidates. · Candidates must be politically independent, possess solid experience in the administration of justice, and be capable of making impartial decisions. · Public presentation of the nominations and personal introductions of the individual candidates. · Independent monitoring of the procedure. · Given the current situation in the country, nothing could increase my confidence. · The removal of all candidates whose professional or political integrity is compromised, as well as unqualified political appointees (*kalinki*) lacking professional experience. · Direct media coverage. · Transparency during the opening of ballots and the tabulation of voting results. Ensuring conditions that allow everyone to vote, including the option to cast a ballot on election day from a location other than one’s primary workplace. · Public dialogue featuring direct, challenging questions from journalists—posed without the judges being informed of them in advance. Public consultation via similar surveys. · Independence. · The incorporation of all the sound proposals listed above. · Fair outcomes in court cases, especially those that serve the public interest. In your opinion, what is the most serious risk regarding the election and the work of the new Supreme Judicial Council (SJC)? · Influence from political parties. · The absence of the conditions mentioned in the previous question. · Voter burnout. · In my view, the personal—and very skillfully concealed—ties that candidates have to specific economic and political circles. Unfortunately, asset and interest declarations are not a sufficient guarantee of an individual's integrity. As the most recently published declarations have shown, it is possible for magistrates within the Supreme Judicial Council (SJC)—who, figuratively speaking, sit at the very top of the judicial system—to go years without declaring a bank account, only to later reveal over 1 million levs in cash. There must be effective mechanisms in place to help identify conflicts of interest in a timely manner; otherwise, we remain in the same situation: predetermined elections, candidates imposed from above under the protection of powerful figures, and obscured evidence of their connections—including the exploitation of legal loopholes to avoid disclosing certain facts. · Election transparency. · Corruption and political pressure. · Oligarchs choosing their own lackeys. · Political interests and interference in the work of the judiciary · The risk remains the same as before: political appointments and influence, eventually leading to control · Continuing in the old way—serving someone else’s interests · Selection based on prior arrangements for both quotas · The desire of politicians to interfere in the work of magistrates and influence personnel appointments within the judicial system · Risk: Will it be possible to effectively distinguish independent judges from those who are compromised/beholden to others? The task: Extremely difficult at the outset. Protection and public support will be required. · The quota-based principle · Interference and dependence on political influence—manifested in a brazen and shameless manner · The appointment of individuals who are compromised and convenient for oligarchic circles Do you have any other recommendations or comments? · Develop a comprehensive system for evaluating judges prior to their appointment to the judiciary, given that these judges subsequently elect their own representatives. · Expose those magistrates who have amassed wealth over the past 36 years and initiate investigations into these "high achievers." · The judicial system must be purged of all "political appointees" from the last 15 years; new competitive selection processes should be held, and the assessment of professional knowledge should be conducted using artificial intelligence rather than relying on the subjective opinion of an "examiner." · Implement special monitoring by foreign experts regarding economic and political ties, as well as membership in Masonic lodges or similar groups. · Keep up the good work! · GOOD LUCK – we are with you! · Thank you for the opportunity provided by this survey to gauge public opinion and gather feedback. Comment: I served as a school principal for 17 years (from 2005 to 2022—one of the few non-political appointments). This gave me indirect exposure to the regulatory framework, followed by a "head-on collision" with the judicial system. The survey helped me realize that, evidently, in every sphere of public life, management is usurped by those in power and exploited for nefarious ends—ends that are, in fact, highly "expedient" for their own "diabolical" schemes, yet deeply harmful to society. If there is any way to change this, I would be fully prepared to get involved!

News13 October 2026

BAWJ Congratulates Judge Navi Pillay on the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize

The Association of Women Judges in Bulgaria joins the International Association of Women Judges (IAWJ)—along with its Board of Directors and Executive Office—in extending its warmest congratulations to Judge Navanethem "Navi" Pillay, a distinguished member of the Association, on being awarded the 2026 Nobel Peace Prize. A trailblazer in the legal profession, Judge Pillay overcame the barriers of apartheid and gender discrimination to establish her legal practice in South Africa in 1967, becoming the first woman attorney of color to run a sole practice in KwaZulu-Natal. She subsequently became the first woman of color to serve as an acting judge of the South African High Court. Her distinguished international career includes service at the United Nations International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda, the International Criminal Court, and as United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights from 2008 to 2014. The IAWJ has been privileged to recognize her extraordinary contributions on two occasions: at our 2000 Biennial Conference in Buenos Aires with the IAWJ Human Rights Award , honoring her pioneering role in advancing international jurisprudence on sexual violence as an act of genocide, and with the Arline Pacht Global Vision Award in 2025 , presented during our 17th Biennial Conference in Cape Town. Judge Pillay's achievement embodies a conviction at the heart of International Association: women judges are not only guardians of the rule of law, but also catalysts for peace, justice, and reconciliation. Her legacy reminds us that lasting peace cannot exist without justice, accountability, and respect for human dignity. As we celebrate this historic recognition, the IAWJ reaffirms its commitment to empowering women judges worldwide as defenders of human rights, champions of judicial independence, and agents of lasting peace. Congratulations, Judge Navi Pillay. You are a source of pride and inspiration for the professional community around the world!

News04 October 2026

The results of the survey regarding the selection of the professional quota for the Judges' Chamber of the Supreme Judicial Council (SJC) reveal after the first ten days

In this short period, the anonymous responses from representatives of the judiciary have outlined clear expectations for the future members of the SJC’s Judges' Chamber and highlighted key issues that the professional community considers priorities. The participant profile shows a predominance of judges (69%), with nearly two-thirds possessing over 11 years of experience. This lends weight to the results, as they reflect the views of individuals with extensive practical experience within the judicial system. What qualities are expected of the candidates? The responses reveal a strong consensus: - Independence and impartiality (83%) - Integrity (76%) - Professional competence (69%) - Understanding of the issues facing the courts (69%) This indicates that the professional community is looking not merely for skilled legal professionals, but for individuals with moral fortitude and a realistic perspective on systemic challenges. Which topics should be prioritized? The most prominent issues identified are: - Personnel policy and selection procedures (72%) - Workload and resource allocation (66%) - Public trust in the judicial system (66%) - Judicial independence (55%) A clear trend emerges here: future members are expected to address not only internal administrative matters but also issues that directly impact the quality of justice and public trust. Transparency and accountability 72% of participants support public hearings, while 66% favor debates. This signals a desire for a more open process in which candidates are visible, subject to scrutiny, and accessible to the professional community. Suggestions for using podcasts indicate a drive toward modern, more accessible forms of communication. Awareness and trust in the procedure Most participants feel at least partially informed (62%), yet a significant proportion remains unfamiliar with the process. Regarding the transparency of current rules, 69% believe they ensure transparency to some extent, while 31% hold a negative view. This suggests a need for improvements and clearer standards. Response to attempted influence 34% would report any pressure exerted, and 24% would not vote for a candidate subject to such influence. However, there are also those who would vote for such a candidate. It is noteworthy that the largest group (38%) does not discuss the topic at all—an indicator of detachment or a reluctance to engage in informal discussions. Trend Analysis 1. High importance placed on moral qualities The data indicate that the professional community prioritizes moral qualities over administrative ones. This is a trend characteristic of systems where there is a sense of external pressure or a lack of trust. 2. Expectation of active reform Issues such as workload, personnel policy, and public trust are paramount. This suggests that the judicial community expects tangible action rather than merely formal administration. 3. Desire for transparency and openness Support for hearings and debates reflects a desire for a process that is visible and shielded from informal influences. 4. Moderate confidence in current rules Responses regarding the transparency of election rules reveal ambivalence; the system is not perceived as entirely reliable. This signals a need for reform within the procedure itself. 5. Low tolerance for pressure, yet a high degree of detachment The willingness to report issues is a new development, but the large proportion of individuals who do not discuss the topic may indicate a fear of conflict or a lack of faith in protection mechanisms. The campaign to elect the professional quota members of the Supreme Judicial Council (SJC) is just beginning, yet the data presented so far can already serve as a snapshot—both for the candidates themselves and for those of us judges considering whom to support. We invite those of you, esteemed colleagues, who have not yet completed the anonymous survey to do so. This is a way to express your views and expectations. Trends may shift or become more pronounced as the process unfolds. We will continue to monitor the situation and keep you informed.

Article29 September 2026

"An Unjustifiably High Number of Judges in the Republic of Bulgaria" – Reality or Perception?

"An Unjustifiably High Number of Judges in the Republic of Bulgaria" – Reality or Perception? Author: Judge Lidia Georgieva, President of the Svoge Regional Court, Member of the Management Board of the Bulgarian Association of Women Judges /BAWJ/ Eurostat recently published data showing that, in 2024, Bulgaria ranked fourth in the European Union (EU) in terms of the number of judges per capita (35.4 judges per 100,000 inhabitants)[1]. The statistics reveal that Croatia and Slovenia hold the top two spots, with 43.3 and 40.2 judges per 100,000 inhabitants respectively, followed by Luxembourg with 36.0 judges per 100,000 inhabitants. Various media outlets and non-governmental organizations have interpreted these data as an indication that the number of judges in Bulgaria is excessive; this has sparked a discussion regarding the need for various staffing and financial measures within the judiciary. The findings regarding the excessive number of judges in Bulgaria are based on data published on the Eurostat website. In this context, it is important to note that Eurostat is the statistical office of the European Commission, responsible for conducting comparative analyses across EU Member States based on specific indicators. However, it should be pointed out that the comparison made by Eurostat relies on a single indicator: the number of judges per capita. Relying solely on this indicator is insufficient to substantiate the claim that the number of judges is excessive. To conduct an accurate and objective analysis and comparison among Member States—one capable of leading to the conclusion that the number of judges in certain states is excessive—multiple factors must be taken into account; examining the ratio of judges per capita is merely one of them. In this context, a key factor to consider is the caseload (the number of cases pending adjudication) relative to the number of judges. Consequently, to ensure the completeness and accuracy of the comparative analysis across Member States, it is necessary to examine a range of factors that manifest differently in each EU country; a comprehensive analysis of these factors allows for an objective conclusion as to whether the number of judges is excessive, sufficient, or inadequate in relation to the population's needs. Although Bulgaria ranks among the top EU countries in terms of the number of judges per capita, it also ranks among the highest in terms of the caseload handled by individual judges. According to the consolidated statistical tables on court activity for 2025[2], the number of cases filed with the courts is steadily increasing (a notable example being the significant rise in civil cases under general procedure heard by regional courts in district centers—103,515 in 2025 compared to 98,820 in 2023). Data published on the website of the Supreme Administrative Court indicates that the total number of cases concluded across the country's 28 administrative courts was 43,337—an increase of 3,104 cases (or 7.72%) compared to the previous year. This trend is primarily attributable to three sets of circumstances: the absence of cases handled by non-judicial bodies; an inadequate state response regarding various legal relationships—which inevitably impacts the judiciary's workload; and the ever-increasing number of proceedings assigned to the courts for adjudication. I. In a number of EU Member States, certain types of proceedings are assigned to non-judicial bodies for resolution. Divorce by mutual consent serves as a prime example. A study conducted by the Court of Justice of the European Union, titled "Out-of-court divorce: rules, procedures and cross-border recognition in the Member States"[3], reveals that many EU Member States—including France, Italy, Spain, Portugal, Romania, and Greece—have implemented non-judicial procedures for handling divorce applications based on mutual consent. The study further suggests that the specific factual elements required to authorize a divorce via a non-judicial body vary across different European countries. However, in all Member States, an agreement between the spouses to terminate their marriage is a necessary element. Additional elements required for this procedure to take place are also observed across the various Member States, such as: a minimum duration of the marriage (Spain), the absence of minor children (Spain and Italy), and an agreement between the spouses regarding the family home (Portugal and Slovenia). Certain exceptions to allowing divorce by mutual consent under this procedure have also been introduced where it is necessary to better protect the child's interests (for instance, in France, out-of-court divorce is not permitted if the child needs to be heard by the court). The agreement reached by the spouses must be in writing, with the exception of Greece, where it is permissible for the spouses' consent to be submitted via a joint digital declaration.In most Member States that provide for the possibility of the extrajudicial dissolution of marriage, the competent authority for such proceedings is a notary (France, Greece, Latvia, and Slovenia) or a civil registrar (Italy and Portugal). Some states also assign a role to the public prosecutor in extrajudicial divorce proceedings when it is necessary to safeguard the rights and interests of children born of the marriage (as is the case in Portugal). Regarding the legal effects of such extrajudicial divorce, it should be noted that in some Member States, the act issued by the extrajudicial authority has the same legal consequences as a court judgment (Portugal and Italy), whereas in other European countries, such an act is classified as an official document that produces binding legal effects. In its analysis, the Court of Justice of the EU concluded that the procedure for the extrajudicial dissolution of marriage simplifies and accelerates the divorce process and relieves courts of a significant caseload, while not entirely precluding judicial intervention when it is necessary to protect the interests of children born of the marriage. The foregoing analysis leads to the conclusion that a number of Member States provide for certain types of cases to be handled by extrajudicial authorities. Implementing such a procedure relieves courts of a large number of cases that do not involve significant factual or legal complexity. In light of the foregoing, and returning to the data published by Eurostat, Spain (6.2 judges per 100,000 inhabitants) and Italy (7.9 judges per 100,000 inhabitants) rank at the bottom regarding the number of judges per capita. However, it is precisely in these countries that provision is made for divorce by mutual consent to be handled by a non-judicial authority, thereby significantly easing the caseload of the courts in these Member States. Furthermore, the fact that Italy ranks high in terms of delayed proceedings—a matter noted in numerous judgments of the European Court of Human Rights (e.g., Bottazzi v. Italy [4]; Verrascina and Others v. Italy [5]; Montalto and Others v. Italy [6])—cannot be overlooked. Against this background, consideration should be given—*de lege ferenda*—to introducing similar non-judicial bodies in Bulgaria to handle specific categories of cases, such as divorce by mutual consent and other non-contentious proceedings (e.g., renunciation and acceptance of inheritance, authorization for the disposal of a child's property, etc.), while safeguarding the public interest and the best interests of the child where necessary. II. The second aspect to consider when analyzing the factors affecting the workload of courts in Bulgaria relates to the inadequate response from the competent executive authorities regarding the established systemic violation of legislation by certain private entities. The activities of non-bank financial institutions providing credit financing as a business serve as an example of this. Despite consistent and settled case law—both from Bulgarian courts and the Court of Justice of the European Union (following requests for preliminary rulings)—regarding the presence of unfair terms in consumer credit contracts and the use of unfair commercial practices by a significant number of financial institutions in Bulgaria, the institutional response remains insufficient. Unlawful practices must be addressed, and appropriate sanctions and regulatory measures must be implemented. In this context, mention should be made of Judgment No. 6438 of 27 May 2024, delivered by the Administrative Court – Sofia in Administrative Case No. 2851/2024, which upheld Judgment No. 784 of 14 February 2024, issued in the administrative penal case... Case No. 15313/2023 on the docket of the Sofia District Court, upholding a penal decree issued by the Acting Director of a Regional Directorate within the General Directorate "Market Control" at the Commission for Consumer Protection, pursuant to Art. 83, para. 1 of the Law on Administrative Violations and Penalties (ZANN) and Art. 232, para. 2 in conjunction with Art. ...Article 210a of the Consumer Protection Act (CPA), whereby the appellant was imposed an administrative penalty in the form of a "pecuniary sanction" amounting to BGN 2,000 (two thousand) for a violation of Article 68e, Paragraph 2, second clause, in conjunction with Article 68g, Paragraph 4, and Article 68c of the CPA. The court established that the financial institution failed to include information regarding costs associated with the credit agreement—as one of its key characteristics—in the Standard European Consumer Credit Information form; instead, the relevant section incorporated information only regarding the event triggering the penalty (failure to secure the agreement with a guarantee from a natural person) and the formula for calculating the daily-accruing penalty claim, thereby creating a genuine risk of misleading the consumer. In light of the cited ruling by the Administrative Court of Sofia City, the enforcement actions taken by the Commission for Consumer Protection upon detecting such violations by financial institutions could be expanded and applied more actively. It should be emphasized that, pursuant to Article 210a of the CPA, violations of Articles 68c, 68g, 68zh (items 1–11, 13, 15, 18–27), and 68k (items 3–6) are punishable by a fine ranging from BGN 1,000 to BGN 30,000 for the liable parties, while... sole traders and legal entities – a pecuniary sanction ranging from BGN 2,000 to BGN 50,000.At the same time, pursuant to Article 232, paragraphs 1 and 2 of the Consumer Protection Act, in cases of a violation of the Act sanctioned by a final penal decree, the supervisory authority proposes the revocation of the license and/or operating permit to the issuing authority. The authority that issued the license and/or operating permit rules on the proposal via a reasoned decision; it immediately notifies the supervisory authority referred to in paragraph 1 of the outcome, and—in the event that it revokes the issued license or permit—specifies the date and grounds for the revocation. Despite the powers granted to the Commission, there has been insufficient activity regarding the taking of measures to identify and impose sanctions for violations related to the terms (clauses) under which non-bank financial institutions provide credit financing. This, in turn, has the direct result of these financial service providers persisting in the use of contracts containing numerous unfair terms. These unfair terms are found in standardized (pre-drafted) contracts provided to consumers, leaving judicial proceedings as the sole avenue for redress. It is precisely this lack of preliminary regulation and failure to identify violations committed by financial institutions—specifically regarding the systematic imposition of unfair contract terms on consumers—that generates a significant volume of civil proceedings (both standard lawsuits and order-for-payment proceedings) requiring adjudication by the courts of the Republic of Bulgaria. III. Proceedings entirely new to Bulgarian jurisprudence are being introduced, with the courts once again tasked with handling them in their entirety. In this context, mention should be made of the personal insolvency proceedings provided for in the newly adopted Personal Insolvency Act. Amendments to the Civil Procedure Code have also been adopted at first reading to introduce a procedure for handling so-called SLAPP cases (Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation). The conclusion to be drawn is that the legislative trend and objective observed in recent years is not to remove certain types of cases—primarily non-contentious proceedings—from the court system; on the contrary, the system is being further burdened with new categories of proceedings. The points outlined above lead to the conclusion that, although Bulgaria ranks high in terms of the number of judges per capita, this should by no means be viewed as an indication of an excessive number of judges; the primary factor to consider is the actual caseload handled by each individual judge. There is a need to rethink the concept of the judiciary’s operations—viewing them not in isolation, but rather within the context of the judiciary's place in the state apparatus; this approach is precisely what would lead to a proper understanding of the judiciary and the identification of the most appropriate measures for its future development.

News22 September 2026

General Meeting of the Bulgarian Association of Women Judges

The Management Board of the Bulgarian Association of Women Judges /BAWJ/ invites you to attend the organization's regular General Assembly. The event will take place on October 24, 2026, from 10:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. in the "Kaloyan" conference hall of the Meridian Bolyarski Hotel, located at 53 Stefan Stambolov St., Veliko Tarnovo. The meeting will proceed according to the following preliminary agenda: 1. Admission of new members. 2. Discussion and adoption of the Strategy for the activities of the Bulgarian Association of Women Judges /BAWJ/ for the 2027–2030 period. 3. Discussion and adoption of the Program for the activities of the Bulgarian Association of Women Judges /BAWJ/ for the 2027–2028 period. 4. Discussion: "Values, Respect, Communication." 5. Discussion on a topical issue: "The election process for the professional quota of the Judges' Chamber of the Supreme Judicial Council of the Republic of Bulgaria." 6. Presentation of ideas for projects and collaborations. Any sitting judge who accepts the Association's Statute, wishes to become a member, and has duly submitted an application to the Management Board via the electronic membership form on the official BAWJ website may register their attendance and participation in the General Assembly. Please confirm your attendance no later than October 16, 2026. by completing the electronic form linked to the invitation ( https://form.jotform.com/262632381309052 ) or by sending an official letter to Judge Nedelina Marinova at the email address: nedelina.marinova@bawj.org ,

Article14 September 2026

Children and Drugs

Every criminal judge comes face to face with the end of a human story in the courtroom. People enter the courtroom when a crime has already been committed, when there is already addiction, broken relationships, wasted years — and sometimes death. There, the judge’s role is clear: to apply the law impartially, on the basis of the evidence and according to their judicial conviction. And to impose punishment. Yet, over the years, I found myself increasingly asking a different question: why did this story begin, and could this painful outcome have been avoided? I have witnessed truly harrowing human stories — parents driven to tie their child to a radiator in a desperate attempt to keep them away from a dealer; men who have lost their self-respect and dignity, their families and friends; death. It was from this question that the Varna Appellate Court’s initiative, “Children and Drugs: Truth and Myths,” was born. Drugs are a part of our lives. We know they are present around schools, in clubs, and at parties; that they are frighteningly easy to obtain; and that new substances are constantly emerging. We hear about yet another arrest, another child who has tried drugs, another young person using drugs. And it seems we have gradually grown accustomed to this — to the point where it is easier to score a dose than to order a pizza. We have developed a tolerance for their very presence. Not because we necessarily approve of them, but because we have come to accept them as an inevitable part of the world we live in. We ask ourselves less and less often why this is the case or whether it truly has to be so. Sometimes, we even uncritically perpetuate one of the most dangerous myths — that there are “dangerous” and “harmless” drugs, that there is addiction and then there is “just trying it,” and that drugs can simply be part of having fun. We must not get used to it. We should not accept it as normal for our children to grow up in an environment where drugs are just another option likely to be offered to them someday. Nor do I think we should resign ourselves to the belief that there is nothing we can do. But change will not come through fear and moralizing. Children do not need another lecture where adults tell them how to live. They need an honest conversation. They need knowledge that allows them to distinguish truth from myth. They need the opportunity to ask questions and receive answers that do not underestimate their ability to think and choose for themselves. That is precisely why, from the very beginning, it was important to me not to enter the classroom alone. I can speak about what I see as a criminal judge. I know drugs through the cases — through the crimes, the punishments, the shattered families, and the human stories behind them. But there is something I cannot — and should not — speak about from personal experience: what it is like to live with addiction. That is why Mitko is there with me at these meetings. He knows addiction not from books, statistics, or court cases, but from his own life. And he has managed to overcome it. When we stand before the children together, they hear the same messages, but from two very different perspectives. I can tell them how drugs appear in the courtroom. Mitko can tell them how, long before that, they enter a person’s life — sometimes almost imperceptibly — through curiosity, the company around them, the desire to fit in, or the conviction that “it won’t happen to me.” Mitko is not an illustration of the judge’s words. He is an equal participant in the conversation. His strength lies in the authenticity of his lived experience. Experience is far more convincing than theory. Mitko does not tell the children what might happen. He tells them what did happen to him. The children ask him things they would likely never ask me or their teacher. And he can answer them not with theory, but with his own story — how addiction gradually changes a person’s choices, relationships, values, freedom, and life itself. But there is something else, too — something particularly important to me. Mitko does not stand before them simply as someone who once lived with addiction. He stands before them as someone who has managed to reclaim his life. These are the kinds of stories I want us to tell. Not stories that point a finger and say, “Look where you could end up,” but stories that show how high the price can be and, at the same time, how powerful human choice can be. Because no one should be defined forever by the hardest period of their life. Over time, I have come to realize that it is precisely this encounter that works — the judge who knows the consequences, and the person who knows the road that leads to them and back. We talk a lot. We tell stories, explain, and sometimes argue. The children ask questions — sometimes directly, sometimes provocatively, sometimes about things adults prefer not to discuss. And that is precisely when the encounter becomes meaningful. Because this is not a lecture about drugs. It is a real conversation about choice and its cost. I don’t know what each child will take away from such a meeting. And I would never claim that a single conversation can protect them from every future risk. But I’ve seen how they listen. How they ask questions. How they challenge us. How, sometimes, they stay behind after the meeting because they still have something they want to say or ask. We adults owe a debt to our children. They are growing up in a world whose rules they did not write and whose dangers they did not create. We hand this world over to them as we have shaped it and allowed it to become. And so we cannot simply expect them to learn on their own how to survive in it. We owe them knowledge. Not knowledge of an ideal world where drugs do not exist, but knowledge of the real one — knowledge that will help them survive within it: to recognize risk, not to believe the myths, to understand that drugs always come at a cost — a cost that varies depending on the choices a person makes, but a cost that is always paid — and to make their own choice even when we are not by their side. For there are no protected children. There are no immune families. Education, a good family, intelligence, love, and care can be a source of strength, but they offer no absolute protection. The thought that “this won’t happen to my child” is perhaps one of the most dangerous myths we adults tell ourselves. And that is why I keep going. We cannot remove drugs from the world our children are growing up in. We cannot be beside them every moment. We cannot make the choice for them. But we can prepare them for the moment when they will have to choose. We can give them knowledge. We can dispel at least one myth. We can leave them with a real human story, a question, or a sentence to hold on to precisely when they need it. For me, this is the meaning of prevention — not the promise that no one will ever make a mistake, but the hope that when a young person faces a choice, they will make it knowingly and thoughtfully. Today, I would like the experience that began with “Children and Drugs: Truth and Myths” to continue and reach more children and young people through the Bulgarian Association of Women Judges’ initiative, “No Myths... I Chose Myself!” I hope we can find other judges willing to step out of the courtroom and talk to young people. I hope we can find others like Mitko — people who have overcome addiction, reclaimed their lives, and are ready to share their experiences honestly and responsibly. I hope we can engage teachers, parents, professionals, and organizations who believe that prevention is a cause we all share. If you believe in this, join us. Because drugs have become part of our lives, but we do not have to accept their presence unquestioningly. Changing this attitude will not happen on its own. It depends on all of us. As judges, we usually encounter a person at the end of their story. With this initiative, I would like us to be there much sooner — when the story can still be written differently. So that when the moment of choice comes, a child will have more reasons to say: “I choose myself.” Svetoslava Koleva Judge at the Varna Court of Appeal